I have 2 of the a GenIII ACSS (5.56 and 7.62x 35/39), Primary Arms packs a lot of value.
I got a Primary Arms model ACOG TA44 1.5x from
@Pbj ak a couple months ago to add to the TA11-J (.223 crosshair 3.5x35) that I already had. I love the ACSS reticle it’s got
To the OP:
The traditional 4x32 ACOGs get a bad rap from people for eye relief because they’re set up with 1.5” eye relief, and the military generally trains NTC shooting for consistency, and based on the ocular lens-to-iron sight line up, the system works as designed. Now, if you aren’t used to shooting like that, it’s a big adjustment which is generally where the complaints come in...and I understand why if that’s not someone’s normal shooting style. The TA11 and 33 models have MUCH better eye relief (TA11 has an inch more and the -33 has half an inch more)
There are things that fixed power optics can’t do that a LPVO can, and in the ACOG price point you can get an optic with clear 1x with little to no distortion. That is appealing BUT then we need to talk about what you’re using the optic for. Mine aren’t for say 3 gun competition, but as I was making 600yd hits last weekend with it, I’d feel comfortable using the TA11 in a medium range (0-4/500) teamed event as a secondary shooter. I primarily use my ACOGs as home defense optics (the 1.5x works better in this role but I have a lot of time invested in point shooting and shooting with both eyes open), I’ve hunted with my TA11 and harvested several deer using it, pest control on farm land, it’s really a do-it-all optic.
The glass is crystal clear (it should be for the price) but fixed power isn’t for everyone. I’d suggest seeing if anyone in your area has one they’d let you try out at the range for a few hours, preferably a range that has distance targets AND a <50yd range that you can try some closer shooting drills with. Anyone who gets behind my rifles at the range are immediately making first round hits on steel from 200 to 500. They are simple and effective.
TL;DR: they’re great optics, I love mine. Not for everyone and they’re not for every situation, but don’t discount their practicality, ease of use, and quality. I also like LPVOs...have owned them, currently own them, and want to own more (of both
)