Best store bought eggnog?

Exile_D

benevolent tyrant
Charter Life Member
Benefactor
Joined
Dec 17, 2016
Messages
8,756
Location
On an accident prone boat (CLT)
Rating - 100%
21   0   0
Which one is your favorite? Go!

So far the Organic Valley eggnog is the best I've tried. Horizon Organic and Trader Joe's are both "blah" at best. Haven't tried SoCo's yet though.

Now homemade eggnog... that is a topic for an entirely different thread... altogether. :D
 
Last edited by a moderator:
There is no such thing as 'best eggnog'...all that nastiness belongs in the trash can
*yuck shivver dry heave*
 
Who in the world drinks that mess. Seems like a Christmas party dare gone wrong.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
draco88;n9281 said:
I have a premonition this thread is going to go much like a discussion about meringue I remember from somewhere..

You just gave me an idea..............the meringue discussion can continue and is thread-worthy. :cool:
 
If you are near a Kroger, then the Homestead Creamery eggnog seems to sell really well. If they don't have that then the Southern Comfort brand sells just as well if not better.
 
I love the nog. I have yet to find any that is great. It's either full of corn syrup or very very bland. If someone knows where to get good stuff let me know.
 
Maple View eggnog is the best I found so far.
 
Well, there's "best," and then there's "best." I like the vanilla spice Southern Comfort, but it's high. Kroger has a vanilla flavor in a 1/2 gallon that's close, but a lot cheaper. Some of the organics are good, but they are REALLY expensive. "Organic" = "expensive" and sometimes "fru-fru." But virtually always "expensive."

Some of the cheaper off-brands have artificial coloring in them; when they have so much that it's blatantly obvious, they generally taste crappy too.

I like to make it from scratch too. Easy to mix up.

My wife still laughs about a Paula Deen episode where she is mixing up eggnog, and says, "If you don't like this much liquor in your eggnog...you cal always add some more." :D
 
I like egg nog, but it don't like me!!

I can drink about 4-6 oz at a time. More than that comes back up
 
The Green Heron;n11924 said:
Sugar, cream, eggs, likker.

What could possibly go wrong?

ll this could be your licker...
 

Attachments

  • ugly_4.jpg
    ugly_4.jpg
    36.7 KB · Views: 0
  • ugly_4.jpg
    ugly_4.jpg
    36.7 KB · Views: 0
Screw store bought! You need to make a batch of this:


World's Greatest Eggnog

Makes 16 to 20 cups (may be cut in half if you know how to divide 1/4 by 2)

4 cups bourbon

2 1/4 cups sugar

12 egg yolks, beaten

8 cups whipping cream


Blend bourbon and sugar in mixing bowl. Let sit overnight, if you can wait. Beat egg yolks until they approach viscous yellow bliss. Add to bourbon mixture. Mix well. Cover and let sit in refrigerator overnight, if you can wait, or at least 2 hours. Whip cream and add to bourbon mixture. Nog starts off very creamy and becomes soupy the longer it survives.


And the story behind it:

Beware: Best eggnog has side effects

ROB KASPER Los Angeles Times Syndicate

THERE are two kinds of eggnog in the world: mine and sorry imitations of mine.

Mine is velvety, creamy and redolent of bourbon. It induces a dreamlike state a poet once referred to as "a long winter's nap."

Soupy imitation eggnogs contain fruit juice, rum or (gag me with a scoop) eggnog ice cream. They are for "people on the go."

Mine is made for people going nowhere. My eggnog is for people who want to remain pleasantly immobile, who want to spend time talking with people they care about. It is a drink for holiday gatherings where the slow ebb and flow of life, rather than a quicksilver business deal, is what people want to talk about.

If this steady-as-she-goes pace bothers you, then my eggnog is not for you.

Nor it is for folks who are phobic about calories, cholesterol or alcohol. My eggnog has all that stuff - in spades.

My eggnog is an old-fashioned, indulgent drink that relies on the old-time remedy of common sense to prevent any abuses.

Which is not to say that there aren't risks involved in drinking my eggnog. There are. Drinking it can lead to singing and to babies. Here are two true-to-life stories.

Story No. 1: Every December, emboldened by a cup of this eggnog, I accompany a recording of Luciano Pavarotti singing "O Holy Night." This duet has frightened pets, silenced small children and embarrassed relatives. But every year, full of eggnog and holiday cheer, I gleefully lift my cup and lift my voice with Luciano.

Story No. 2: In December 1981, I introduced a couple - young, professional and childless - to this eggnog. One year later the eggnog and a bouncing baby boy were permanent parts of this couple's holiday celebration. But now that the couple has two young children, their intake of eggnog, if not their enthusiasm for it, has moderated.

I am frequently asked questions about my eggnog. Questions like, "Is it a lot of work to make?"

The answer is, "Yes." The first step of the eggnog-making procedure, mixing the sugar and the bourbon, begins the night before the completed elixir is served. But the overnight rule is flexible. A few hours of serious stirring can substitute for an overnight soaking.

Another often-asked question is, "Is it permissible to lick stray eggnog off lips?" The answer again is, "Yes." Licking of lips, both yours and others, is permitted, but that, too, can lead to children.

Still another question I get is, "How many calories are in this eggnog?" The short answer is: beyond calculation. I lost my nerve when the total of half the ingredients in the recipe topped 6,000. But the calorie total should be divided by 20 if you serve the eggnog in big cups or by 30 if you serve it in petite portions.

The next question usually is, "Is this eggnog worth the trouble and calories?" You bet your little bowl full of jelly it is.

Drinking this eggnog ranks right up there in holiday pleasures with peeling tangerines and watching kids open presents on Christmas morning.
 
Don;n12188 said:
Screw store bought! You need to make a batch of this:


World's Greatest Eggnog

Makes 16 to 20 cups (may be cut in half if you know how to divide 1/4 by 2)

4 cups bourbon

2 1/4 cups sugar

12 egg yolks, beaten

8 cups whipping cream


Blend bourbon and sugar in mixing bowl. Let sit overnight, if you can wait. Beat egg yolks until they approach viscous yellow bliss. Add to bourbon mixture. Mix well. Cover and let sit in refrigerator overnight, if you can wait, or at least 2 hours. Whip cream and add to bourbon mixture. Nog starts off very creamy and becomes soupy the longer it survives.


And the story behind it:

Beware: Best eggnog has side effects

ROB KASPER Los Angeles Times Syndicate

THERE are two kinds of eggnog in the world: mine and sorry imitations of mine.

Mine is velvety, creamy and redolent of bourbon. It induces a dreamlike state a poet once referred to as "a long winter's nap."

Soupy imitation eggnogs contain fruit juice, rum or (gag me with a scoop) eggnog ice cream. They are for "people on the go."

Mine is made for people going nowhere. My eggnog is for people who want to remain pleasantly immobile, who want to spend time talking with people they care about. It is a drink for holiday gatherings where the slow ebb and flow of life, rather than a quicksilver business deal, is what people want to talk about.

If this steady-as-she-goes pace bothers you, then my eggnog is not for you.

Nor it is for folks who are phobic about calories, cholesterol or alcohol. My eggnog has all that stuff - in spades.

My eggnog is an old-fashioned, indulgent drink that relies on the old-time remedy of common sense to prevent any abuses.

Which is not to say that there aren't risks involved in drinking my eggnog. There are. Drinking it can lead to singing and to babies. Here are two true-to-life stories.

Story No. 1: Every December, emboldened by a cup of this eggnog, I accompany a recording of Luciano Pavarotti singing "O Holy Night." This duet has frightened pets, silenced small children and embarrassed relatives. But every year, full of eggnog and holiday cheer, I gleefully lift my cup and lift my voice with Luciano.

Story No. 2: In December 1981, I introduced a couple - young, professional and childless - to this eggnog. One year later the eggnog and a bouncing baby boy were permanent parts of this couple's holiday celebration. But now that the couple has two young children, their intake of eggnog, if not their enthusiasm for it, has moderated.

I am frequently asked questions about my eggnog. Questions like, "Is it a lot of work to make?"

The answer is, "Yes." The first step of the eggnog-making procedure, mixing the sugar and the bourbon, begins the night before the completed elixir is served. But the overnight rule is flexible. A few hours of serious stirring can substitute for an overnight soaking.

Another often-asked question is, "Is it permissible to lick stray eggnog off lips?" The answer again is, "Yes." Licking of lips, both yours and others, is permitted, but that, too, can lead to children.

Still another question I get is, "How many calories are in this eggnog?" The short answer is: beyond calculation. I lost my nerve when the total of half the ingredients in the recipe topped 6,000. But the calorie total should be divided by 20 if you serve the eggnog in big cups or by 30 if you serve it in petite portions.

The next question usually is, "Is this eggnog worth the trouble and calories?" You bet your little bowl full of jelly it is.

Drinking this eggnog ranks right up there in holiday pleasures with peeling tangerines and watching kids open presents on Christmas morning.

Looks like we got a new recipe to try this year! You should post this in the cooking section too Don ;)
 
Zedhound said:
I love the nog. I have yet to find any that is great. It's either full of corn syrup or very very bland. If someone knows where to get good stuff let me know.
That Organic Valley eggnog isn't full of the HFCS and still has a decent flavor.
 
RFMan said:
Well, there's "best," and then there's "best." I like the vanilla spice Southern Comfort, but it's high. Kroger has a vanilla flavor in a 1/2 gallon that's close, but a lot cheaper. Some of the organics are good, but they are REALLY expensive. "Organic" = "expensive" and sometimes "fru-fru." But virtually always "expensive."

Some of the cheaper off-brands have artificial coloring in them; when they have so much that it's blatantly obvious, they generally taste crappy too.

I like to make it from scratch too. Easy to mix up.

My wife still laughs about a Paula Deen episode where she is mixing up eggnog, and says, "If you don't like this much liquor in your eggnog...you cal always add some more." :D
My wife and I laughed at that too! Unfortunately if you don't want all the coloring, HFCS, etc. you have to go with the organic, at least around here.
Although Don's looks like it is worth trying out!
 
Exile_D;n9257 said:
Which one is your favorite? Go!

So far the Organic Valley eggnog is the best I've tried. Horizon Organic and Trader Joe's are both "blah" at best. Haven't tried SoCo's yet though.

Now homemade eggnog... that is a topic for an entirely different thread... altogether. :D

After having some homemade stuff with eggs from my backyard chickens, store bought shit is just that... shit
 
Non-alcoholic award goes to Hood. Those flavored eggnogs (Sugar Cookie, Gingerbread, Pumpkin) is awesome.
Best alcoholic is Evan Williams, but homemade far surpasses that.
 
Exile_D said:
Don;n12188 said:
Screw store bought! You need to make a batch of this:


World's Greatest Eggnog

Makes 16 to 20 cups (may be cut in half if you know how to divide 1/4 by 2)

4 cups bourbon

2 1/4 cups sugar

12 egg yolks, beaten

8 cups whipping cream


Blend bourbon and sugar in mixing bowl. Let sit overnight, if you can wait. Beat egg yolks until they approach viscous yellow bliss. Add to bourbon mixture. Mix well. Cover and let sit in refrigerator overnight, if you can wait, or at least 2 hours. Whip cream and add to bourbon mixture. Nog starts off very creamy and becomes soupy the longer it survives.


And the story behind it:

Beware: Best eggnog has side effects

ROB KASPER Los Angeles Times Syndicate

THERE are two kinds of eggnog in the world: mine and sorry imitations of mine.

Mine is velvety, creamy and redolent of bourbon. It induces a dreamlike state a poet once referred to as "a long winter's nap."

Soupy imitation eggnogs contain fruit juice, rum or (gag me with a scoop) eggnog ice cream. They are for "people on the go."

Mine is made for people going nowhere. My eggnog is for people who want to remain pleasantly immobile, who want to spend time talking with people they care about. It is a drink for holiday gatherings where the slow ebb and flow of life, rather than a quicksilver business deal, is what people want to talk about.

If this steady-as-she-goes pace bothers you, then my eggnog is not for you.

Nor it is for folks who are phobic about calories, cholesterol or alcohol. My eggnog has all that stuff - in spades.

My eggnog is an old-fashioned, indulgent drink that relies on the old-time remedy of common sense to prevent any abuses.

Which is not to say that there aren't risks involved in drinking my eggnog. There are. Drinking it can lead to singing and to babies. Here are two true-to-life stories.

Story No. 1: Every December, emboldened by a cup of this eggnog, I accompany a recording of Luciano Pavarotti singing "O Holy Night." This duet has frightened pets, silenced small children and embarrassed relatives. But every year, full of eggnog and holiday cheer, I gleefully lift my cup and lift my voice with Luciano.

Story No. 2: In December 1981, I introduced a couple - young, professional and childless - to this eggnog. One year later the eggnog and a bouncing baby boy were permanent parts of this couple's holiday celebration. But now that the couple has two young children, their intake of eggnog, if not their enthusiasm for it, has moderated.

I am frequently asked questions about my eggnog. Questions like, "Is it a lot of work to make?"

The answer is, "Yes." The first step of the eggnog-making procedure, mixing the sugar and the bourbon, begins the night before the completed elixir is served. But the overnight rule is flexible. A few hours of serious stirring can substitute for an overnight soaking.

Another often-asked question is, "Is it permissible to lick stray eggnog off lips?" The answer again is, "Yes." Licking of lips, both yours and others, is permitted, but that, too, can lead to children.

Still another question I get is, "How many calories are in this eggnog?" The short answer is: beyond calculation. I lost my nerve when the total of half the ingredients in the recipe topped 6,000. But the calorie total should be divided by 20 if you serve the eggnog in big cups or by 30 if you serve it in petite portions.

The next question usually is, "Is this eggnog worth the trouble and calories?" You bet your little bowl full of jelly it is.

Drinking this eggnog ranks right up there in holiday pleasures with peeling tangerines and watching kids open presents on Christmas morning.

Looks like we got a new recipe to try this year! You should post this in the cooking section too Don ;)
Will do. I'm going to be reposting most of my recipes from the other place.

A word of caution: you'd better really like the taste of bourbon if you make the above recipe, because the flavor really jumps out at you. But it's some good stuff!!
 
Exile_D said:
Don;n12188 said:
Screw store bought! You need to make a batch of this:


World's Greatest Eggnog

Makes 16 to 20 cups (may be cut in half if you know how to divide 1/4 by 2)

4 cups bourbon

2 1/4 cups sugar

12 egg yolks, beaten

8 cups whipping cream


Blend bourbon and sugar in mixing bowl. Let sit overnight, if you can wait. Beat egg yolks until they approach viscous yellow bliss. Add to bourbon mixture. Mix well. Cover and let sit in refrigerator overnight, if you can wait, or at least 2 hours. Whip cream and add to bourbon mixture. Nog starts off very creamy and becomes soupy the longer it survives.


And the story behind it:

Beware: Best eggnog has side effects

ROB KASPER Los Angeles Times Syndicate

THERE are two kinds of eggnog in the world: mine and sorry imitations of mine.

Mine is velvety, creamy and redolent of bourbon. It induces a dreamlike state a poet once referred to as "a long winter's nap."

Soupy imitation eggnogs contain fruit juice, rum or (gag me with a scoop) eggnog ice cream. They are for "people on the go."

Mine is made for people going nowhere. My eggnog is for people who want to remain pleasantly immobile, who want to spend time talking with people they care about. It is a drink for holiday gatherings where the slow ebb and flow of life, rather than a quicksilver business deal, is what people want to talk about.

If this steady-as-she-goes pace bothers you, then my eggnog is not for you.

Nor it is for folks who are phobic about calories, cholesterol or alcohol. My eggnog has all that stuff - in spades.

My eggnog is an old-fashioned, indulgent drink that relies on the old-time remedy of common sense to prevent any abuses.

Which is not to say that there aren't risks involved in drinking my eggnog. There are. Drinking it can lead to singing and to babies. Here are two true-to-life stories.

Story No. 1: Every December, emboldened by a cup of this eggnog, I accompany a recording of Luciano Pavarotti singing "O Holy Night." This duet has frightened pets, silenced small children and embarrassed relatives. But every year, full of eggnog and holiday cheer, I gleefully lift my cup and lift my voice with Luciano.

Story No. 2: In December 1981, I introduced a couple - young, professional and childless - to this eggnog. One year later the eggnog and a bouncing baby boy were permanent parts of this couple's holiday celebration. But now that the couple has two young children, their intake of eggnog, if not their enthusiasm for it, has moderated.

I am frequently asked questions about my eggnog. Questions like, "Is it a lot of work to make?"

The answer is, "Yes." The first step of the eggnog-making procedure, mixing the sugar and the bourbon, begins the night before the completed elixir is served. But the overnight rule is flexible. A few hours of serious stirring can substitute for an overnight soaking.

Another often-asked question is, "Is it permissible to lick stray eggnog off lips?" The answer again is, "Yes." Licking of lips, both yours and others, is permitted, but that, too, can lead to children.

Still another question I get is, "How many calories are in this eggnog?" The short answer is: beyond calculation. I lost my nerve when the total of half the ingredients in the recipe topped 6,000. But the calorie total should be divided by 20 if you serve the eggnog in big cups or by 30 if you serve it in petite portions.

The next question usually is, "Is this eggnog worth the trouble and calories?" You bet your little bowl full of jelly it is.

Drinking this eggnog ranks right up there in holiday pleasures with peeling tangerines and watching kids open presents on Christmas morning.

Looks like we got a new recipe to try this year! You should post this in the cooking section too Don ;)
Not a problem on the bourbon taste! ;) Just tried Buffalo Trace's Bourbon Creme, not bad. Hey... it may go well in the store bought eggnog!
 
As AD43576 mentioned.

[IMG2=JSON]{"data-align":"none","data-size":"full","src":"http:\/\/tse2.mm.bing.net\/th?id=OIP.M76f90c86b286a2dbcdea0239d15b3afco0&pid=15.1"}[/IMG2]

I don't drink egg nog, but when I do.....
 
Mad Dawg said:
As AD43576 mentioned.

[IMG2=JSON]{"data-align":"none","data-size":"full","src":"http:\/\/tse2.mm.bing.net\/th?id=OIP.M76f90c86b286a2dbcdea0239d15b3afco0&pid=15.1"}[/IMG2]

I don't drink egg nog, but when I do.....
Seem to be several fans of the Evan Williams. Guess I gotta try it. Now just to find it in a store around here!
 
Exile_D said:
Don;n12188 said:
Screw store bought! You need to make a batch of this:


World's Greatest Eggnog

Makes 16 to 20 cups (may be cut in half if you know how to divide 1/4 by 2)

4 cups bourbon

2 1/4 cups sugar

12 egg yolks, beaten

8 cups whipping cream


Blend bourbon and sugar in mixing bowl. Let sit overnight, if you can wait. Beat egg yolks until they approach viscous yellow bliss. Add to bourbon mixture. Mix well. Cover and let sit in refrigerator overnight, if you can wait, or at least 2 hours. Whip cream and add to bourbon mixture. Nog starts off very creamy and becomes soupy the longer it survives.


And the story behind it:

Beware: Best eggnog has side effects

ROB KASPER Los Angeles Times Syndicate

THERE are two kinds of eggnog in the world: mine and sorry imitations of mine.

Mine is velvety, creamy and redolent of bourbon. It induces a dreamlike state a poet once referred to as "a long winter's nap."

Soupy imitation eggnogs contain fruit juice, rum or (gag me with a scoop) eggnog ice cream. They are for "people on the go."

Mine is made for people going nowhere. My eggnog is for people who want to remain pleasantly immobile, who want to spend time talking with people they care about. It is a drink for holiday gatherings where the slow ebb and flow of life, rather than a quicksilver business deal, is what people want to talk about.

If this steady-as-she-goes pace bothers you, then my eggnog is not for you.

Nor it is for folks who are phobic about calories, cholesterol or alcohol. My eggnog has all that stuff - in spades.

My eggnog is an old-fashioned, indulgent drink that relies on the old-time remedy of common sense to prevent any abuses.

Which is not to say that there aren't risks involved in drinking my eggnog. There are. Drinking it can lead to singing and to babies. Here are two true-to-life stories.

Story No. 1: Every December, emboldened by a cup of this eggnog, I accompany a recording of Luciano Pavarotti singing "O Holy Night." This duet has frightened pets, silenced small children and embarrassed relatives. But every year, full of eggnog and holiday cheer, I gleefully lift my cup and lift my voice with Luciano.

Story No. 2: In December 1981, I introduced a couple - young, professional and childless - to this eggnog. One year later the eggnog and a bouncing baby boy were permanent parts of this couple's holiday celebration. But now that the couple has two young children, their intake of eggnog, if not their enthusiasm for it, has moderated.

I am frequently asked questions about my eggnog. Questions like, "Is it a lot of work to make?"

The answer is, "Yes." The first step of the eggnog-making procedure, mixing the sugar and the bourbon, begins the night before the completed elixir is served. But the overnight rule is flexible. A few hours of serious stirring can substitute for an overnight soaking.

Another often-asked question is, "Is it permissible to lick stray eggnog off lips?" The answer again is, "Yes." Licking of lips, both yours and others, is permitted, but that, too, can lead to children.

Still another question I get is, "How many calories are in this eggnog?" The short answer is: beyond calculation. I lost my nerve when the total of half the ingredients in the recipe topped 6,000. But the calorie total should be divided by 20 if you serve the eggnog in big cups or by 30 if you serve it in petite portions.

The next question usually is, "Is this eggnog worth the trouble and calories?" You bet your little bowl full of jelly it is.

Drinking this eggnog ranks right up there in holiday pleasures with peeling tangerines and watching kids open presents on Christmas morning.

Looks like we got a new recipe to try this year! You should post this in the cooking section too Don ;)
Dang! That sounds like something I might have to try for New Year's. :)

Post the recipe in the Cooking w wolfie? or another one?
 
Mad Dawg said:
As AD43576 mentioned.

[IMG2=JSON]{"data-align":"none","data-size":"full","src":"http:\/\/tse2.mm.bing.net\/th?id=OIP.M76f90c86b286a2dbcdea0239d15b3afco0&pid=15.1"}[/IMG2]

I don't drink egg nog, but when I do.....
Just be sure to shake it VERY WELL!
 
Back
Top Bottom