We need one for the 32' camper. It appears the solid bars are a better option than the chain type. What's the best bang for the buck, and your experience?
Do you have a picture of the chain type that you are talking about? I have a setup like @Scsmith42 described (chains on the end of solid bars) And it does not require a separate swaybarFrom some of the research I've read, the chain type will need a separate sway bar that needs to be removed for tighter turns & parking. The solid bars are noisy, but remove sway.
This is what I have. The camlock bars work really well to keep things stable on the highway. They do make a pop noise when turning sharply on city streets or turning at the end of an exit ramp. When I get to the campground or my house, I just remove the load bars because I don’t need them at that point, and they don’t make any noise after that.Do you have a picture of the chain type that you are talking about? I have a setup like @Scsmith42 described (chains on the end of solid bars) And it does not require a separate swaybar
That exact one is one that we’ve used for 100k plus miles.I have used this one for, I'd bet 200k, miles. If not more. It does what it's supposed to do. And does it very well. https://m.northerntool.com/shop/tools/product_200853429_200853429?cm_mmc=Google-LIA&utm_source=Google_LIA&utm_medium=Trailers + Towing > Towing Accessories > Weight Distribution Kits&utm_campaign=Curt Manufacturing&utm_content=4413443&gclid=Cj0KCQiAsoycBhC6ARIsAPPbeLsD7rbygDcKmgXyrp8m2EbGM-8dzKi_OEnKbJ336oTiHsJyDVb39LcaAlDeEALw_wcB&gclsrc=aw.ds
If you look into the design it uses set screws not clamp force. It’s not a new design and has very good reviews.No disrespect, but I would not want to use that Anderson design on any of my trailers.
For one thing, in order for it to work you're depending upon the friction of the clamps mounted to the trailer tongue, as the chain will be trying to pull them forward when it's in tension. I foresee clamp slippage when the truck/trailer goes over rough roads.
It might work for very light duty applications, but I would not trust it to a trailer of any significant size / weight.
I'm probably overthinking it. Much of what I tow is pretty heavy so I tend to go overkill when it comes to trailer components.If you look into the design it uses set screws not clamp force.
I feel ya, every design has its pros and cons. Like I said I haven’t tried it yet but the internet says it’s good to go so we’ll see LOL. Main advantages to me were no bounce, noise, and no issues backing up with it. Plus it weighs less than the other styles.I'm probably overthinking it. Much of what I tow is pretty heavy so I tend to go overkill when it comes to trailer components.
That style but a different brand? Did a lot of research on that particular brand and model and pretty much everyone loves it. Time will tell I guess.If you are expecting less bounce,I think you will be disappointed.They work for sway but that's about it.
I towed for a friend using that style. Never a
gain. He towed with mine, linked above, and alot more weight, and promptly switched.
The challenge with so many online reviews is that many of the reviewers are inexperienced, and quite frankly don’t know what they are talking about. They’ve never tried different products and thus have a one dimensional opinion Based on their new experience. They don’t have anything to compare it to.That style but a different brand? Did a lot of research on that particular brand and model and pretty much everyone loves it. Time will tell I guess.
I get it people tend to stick with what they know.The challenge with so many online reviews is that many of the reviewers are inexperienced, and quite frankly don’t know what they are talking about. They’ve never tried different products and thus have a one dimensional opinion Based on their new experience. They don’t have anything to compare it to.
I have hundreds of thousands of miles of towing experience over a 45 year time period. Lee Majors probably has something similar. Everything from towing with cars to towing with semi’s, and everything in-between. Single, dual, Tri-axle and dual tandem trailers, as well as low boys. I’ve owned three different WD hitches just in the past 22 years. I currently own eight on road trailers and four off-road ones and previously owned large campers.
And since I’m the guy who is repairing them when they break, I’m pretty focused on what works and what doesn’t.
The Anderson design is not one that I’d have high expectations from.
YMMV.
I‘m not trying to beat you up over this; I’m really interested in what your experience is. It’s just that the OP is a personal friend who has done me some favors and I don’t want him to have a bad experience.
Looking through yootoob RV folk reviews, this one looked to be the best bang for the buck. There was one on FB for $150. Unlike CFF, FB let’s losers lie and not get banned.Do you have a picture of the chain type that you are talking about? I have a setup like @Scsmith42 described (chains on the end of solid bars) And it does not require a separate swaybar