J-frame Model 442 vs. Bodyguard 38 special

[Papermaker]

What is the difference between the M442 and the M&P Bodyguard 38 special revolver? I have a M442 and like it, and am considering purchasing another while firearms are priced attractively. I noticed that the Bodyguard 38 special is priced lower. Wondering what the difference is? Thanks in advance for any input!!!

 

[Jeppo]

 

[BatteryOaksBilly]

Try to find a real BodyGuard. An original model 38.

 

[Tim]

short answer is 642/442 have aluminum frames while the new model BodyGuard is polymer.

 

[Radar]

The 442/642 is better in my opinion and I have owned both at one time or another

 

[Red Marley]

Interestingly, I have also owned both the .38 Bodyguard and a PC 642. The Bodyguard had (has!) a noticeably better DA trigger, and I shot it better; not to mention it's lighter to carry. I still have the Bodyguard but not the 642. Go figure. I imagine the difference is down to production variations.

 

[Bull Durham]

I have a .38 Bodyguard with the a Crimson Trace laser and have learned to shoot it. I wear it a lot in a “Clinger” AIWB Kydex rig when I’m at the forge and can’t help but sweat all over it. No worries about surface rust yet with the polymer. It’s so light and comfortable that I forget that I have it on most days so it’s a solid summer carry piece.

 

[Combat Diver]

The newer Bodyguard does have a different cylinder release.

CD

 

[Radar]

@Combat Diver is correct it has a different latch to release the cylinder. You also can get the Bodyguard revolver without a laser too I believe.

 

[NCMedic]

I had both a Bodyguard 38 as well as a 442.

I sold the 442 and kept the Bodyguard, lighter but felt more shootable to me. Also as a lefty, the top latch is easier for me to operate.
Mine has the laser which is push button activated, being left handed I've found I can activate it with my thumb when I am getting a grip on the gun during the draw.