why does this thread seem like “should i get a hi-point, glock, sig or hk?”
going off road is similar to self-defense, as it seems that situational awareness and avoiding trouble are more important than the tools that you have to get you out of trouble.
in my experience with mud, The only time tires make a difference is when they’re TRUE mud tires which will generally suck on the highway and wear fast.
for the kind of trail driving that you’re talking about any mild all-terrain should be fine.
if you’re REALLY worried about getting stuck, then, as mentioned before, selectable lockers and a winch are better investments.
that said, since most people get tires for the way they look I like the way the BFG‘s and Goodyear Duratracs look. i’ve gotten 50 K miles out of each of those brands, but if you don’t rotate more aggressive tires they get uneven and louder as they get older.