CLEO notification forwarded to local sheriff

Nonsense.

How very helpful and full of facts. What grade are you in?

I thought I was being helpful when I stated that the CLEO is the Sheriff and BigW opted to get insulting and it all went sideways from there.


Wrong.

@JGC1524 why are you so defensive?

Edit: I went back and read the whole thread. @JGC1524 has been the most to belittle In your posts.
Eluding to name dropping, being the most authoritative, and generally being a jerk and not accepting another persons viewpoint.
It’s dang near bullying. Why do you feel this is acceptable behavior?
 
Last edited:
Eluding to name dropping, being the most authoritative, and generally being a jerk and not accepting another persons viewpoint.
It’s dang near bullying. Why do you feel this is acceptable behavior?
AND....fer's I kin tell...he ain't got a train...so....No Engineer!
 
Me thinks we've been trolled.
Without sharing too much, there have been some extenuating circumstances that are most likely the reason he’s not been responding in the last day or so.
 
Without sharing too much, there have been some extenuating circumstances that are most likely the reason he’s not been responding in the last day or so.

Of a personal nature?.. I hope him and his Family are well and I’ll say a prayer.

If of an alligator mouth on a hummingbird ass nature... Well, Bye..
 
  • Like
Reactions: Me.
Of a personal nature?.. I hope him and his Family are well and I’ll say a prayer.

If of an alligator mouth on a hummingbird ass nature... Well, Bye..
The first
 
Maybe the atf rep that's a member here will respond at some point.
They didn’t respond, but somebody is watching. I got 10 envelopes from the NFA Division today. 😳

0F66739B-E87A-429B-8820-62B176BC2E1C.jpeg
 
My wife and I were t boned yesterday by someone who ran a red light and rolled our jeep. Witnesses said they were traveling at least 45 and never hit the brakes.

WHY would I be trolling and what would I gain by bothering to argue about something like this? I had stated I was done with this thread as no good was coming from it and I was fighting a losing battle. But because I decided to ignore the continued sarcasm, I must be a troll? Its lose - lose either way for me. Continue to post here, I get railed on with mostly emojis, gifs, and cartoons posted to be sarcasticor insulting, stop posting to let it go, and Im a troll. No win situation. I decided to just let it go, others just cannot.

Not lying about the accident, here it is, yesterday morning.

20210709_102057.jpg

I had spoken to a captain at Wake County Sheriffs office Thursday which i mentioned. Yesterday at 4pm a lieutenant called me while I was in the ER waiting room because he thought he was returning a call not realizing that his captain had already called me back. He asked me why I called and I told him and his response was yeah many people read the general language in the atf's instructions to mean they can send it to any of those individuals. And he also told me that he gets them forwarded to him all the time from the chief of police in Garner from the chief of police in Raleigh from the state highway patrol Etc. He was clear that they're supposed to come to the Sheriff and that's why they are ultimately forwarded to them when they go elsewhere. He also stated that the county Sheriffs office is the one designated to maintain the NFA files.

So people are posting saying well I sent mine here I sent mine there and it still got approved and everyone still fails to understand what it is that I said. Since each state designates a different position as the CLEO, the ATF lists the various positions that could entail and it's up to the individual to send it to the proper one in his specific location. The feds take care of thier part, the applicant is expected to know the local laws of his state. All they're looking for is that you sent it they don't check nor do the individual agents that process these forms know who the Cleo is in all 50 states. So the answer to a question that was posed to me before - has the ATF made errors and the answer is yes they have because the individuals processing the forms are looking to see the notification was sent that's all. Does it mean the stamp is 100% valid because the ATF accepted that? No, it's OUR responsibility to abide by the laws of our state, Its not the ATFs job to double-check that, they are simply asking that notification be sent, they see that it was and they move on to the next step in the process review.

So the ATF sees notification was sent but if it's sent to the wrong entity that is not the "state recognized" Cleo and it doesn't get forwarded to the sheriff, then technically the individual is in violation of both the federal rule because he did not notify the Cleo and he's in violation at a state level because the state expects proper notification be sent regarding NFA items.

The point is if you firmly and absolutely believe that there is more than one chief law enforcement officer in any one location which in itself doesn't make sense, thats fine. But I don't think this is something to have a Cavalier attitude on if the proper notification wasn't made it could legally invalidate the stamp.

Nevermind the personal BS with whether or not any of you like me or like what i am saying. if I am right then some people could have potentially invalid stamps if they're notification wasn't forwarded to the sheriff by whoever they sent it to. Why let a potential problem continue on something like this? I just don't understand why no one wants to know for sure and just blindly go along with the "well this has worked before" attitude.

To admit that I'm right would potentially mean that some of you sent it to the wrong place and nobody wants to hear that, so the argument continues. But if that's the case then simply burying your head in the sand and not wanting to know doesn't fix it either.

It's easy enough without causing any issues for yourself or anyone else if you're planning on sending it to the state highway patrol or wherever, call first and ask "Hey I'm going to send notification about an NFA item I am purchasing and I want to make sure that you are the right recipient" that would be easy enough to do you're simply doing due diligence and asking before you send. The answer you get will tell you if you're right there's no harm in doing that, correct? Either they say yes send it or no I'm not the right person. No harm no foul. There is no risk in asking that question, other than hearing an answer that some of you don't want to hear.

So, can we please dispense with the endless gifs, emojis and sarcasm? If you believe you're doing the right thing and you don't care what I said by all means that's your right no argument. But as I pointed out if you have any doubt what is the harm in making that call? We're talking about NFA items here, I would think that anybody putting in the paperwork would want to be a hundred percent sure for themselves and not just base their decision on an argument in an internet forum.
 
If no one cares it would have ended when I stopped posting but since then there's been numerous posts with insults and sarcasm. When I didn't respond to any of those then someone says I must be a troll because I'm not responding anymore.

I say something and you immediately pounce, stop responding and I'm a troll.
 
He also stated that the county Sheriffs office is the one designated to maintain the NFA files.
This is not directed at you…just a general comment based on what was stated.

It’s just another example of LEO power-tripping, and making up things that don’t exist. There are no requirements for any NFA files to be maintained. Not pre-41F or after 41F.

They were even told by the ATF they could toss ‘em (the notifications) in the trash in a letter explaining 41F.

BD5D1F8C-98EA-43B1-A5DB-C24F6BF424EB.jpeg
EFDE0EFE-BA05-44AE-93FB-8C97EFEA49C8.jpeg
 
You are probably right, Im sure a database of who owns what is what they would like. You know how government is be it state or federal.
 
@JGC1524
First off, I hope you and your wife were not seriously hurt from the Tbone, and that what was hurt is made whole quickly.

now, just because you say to stop … actually means a sign of weakness.
It’s not going to end well with that.
Good luck in your future endeavors.
 
Now desiring to stop an argument is a sign of weakness? I beg to differ, only a fool fights in a burning house. There comes a time to cut your losses and drop it. What is your suggestion, we keep arguing until when exactly? Why do we keep arguing? Enlighten me.

Argue and your an *******, stop replying to insults and your a troll, asking to do the adult thing and stop arguing is weakness.

I mean seriously guys, if that's how you all feel I'm done here and gone.
 
Last edited:
You are probably right, Im sure a database of who owns what is what they would like.


In my experience with this process, no they wouldn't .

Local LEO's have 2x too much on their plate to care about legal NFA owners federal paperwork. They really could not care less.

Glad you're OK!
 
Last edited:
If no one cares it would have ended when I stopped posting but since then there's been numerous posts with insults and sarcasm. When I didn't respond to any of those then someone says I must be a troll because I'm not responding anymore.

I say something and you immediately pounce, stop responding and I'm a troll.
I said you were trolling because you disappeared from the conversation after we were all fired up. I did not realize you were going through some hardships and I do apologize for that mistake.
 
How very helpful and full of facts. What grade are you in?

First off, I sincerely hope that you and your wife are ok from the accident, and if not that your recovery is swift and complete.

CFF is a great forum. Many of us have been posting here for years and as such have developed friendships - both online as well as in-person. You have not been here long enough to observe this, but hopefully you will stick around. There are almost daily examples of members helping other members - many times folks that they have not even met - just because most of us are good folks and want to support fellow firearms enthusiasts.

The reason that you're getting hammered in this thread is primarily because of the statement quoted above. As Rambo would say, "you drew first blood" by making the quoted derogatory statement against a member that is highly respected here for not only his knowledge about NFA laws and regulations, but also his long history of generously devoting a lot of time helping others understand the process and how to avoid minefields when doing the paperwork. You followed up by becoming defensive when others tried to explain otherwise.

To my knowledge, there is no "law" in NC that designates the local county Sherriff as the CLEO for NFA notification purposes. It sounds as if the new State Highway Patrol chief has adopted a new "policy" about this, but Department Policy is not the same as State Law. If there is a LAW designating the local Sherriff as CLEO for NFA purposes, then by all means please post the reference so that all of us can learn and change our actions accordingly. The "opinion" of a deputy or clerk does not constitute Law, which is another reason why you're getting hammered because of the credence that you're associating with folks that historically have been proven ignorant about this area of state and federal law.

NC State Law does not require that NFA owners notify their local CLEO, but it does require that NFA owners follow the federal NFA laws as previously referenced herein. It is Federal law that designates that a CLEO has to be notified, and the Fed's provide a variety of options as to who is an acceptable CLEO.

The Feds say that SHP, AG, DA, Sherriff, Police Chief, Judges, etc are all acceptable CLEO's, and to my knowledge nothing in NC State LAW contradicts this. Not following a state "policy" by notifying SHP as a CLEO instead of your local Sherriff does not make one in violation of Federal LAW. This seems to be a nuance that you are unwilling to accept based upon your comments in this thread.

There are many Sherriff's in NC that do not support the rights of citizens with respect to firearms - especially NFA firearms. Governor Cooper certainly falls into that category, based upon his advice to the Sherriff's (when he was AG) not to sign off on Form 4 transfer requests even though NFA ownership has bee legal in NC for decades. We are fortunate that ATF changed the rules a few years ago and removed the CLEO's as part of the decision making process, as many were denying NC Citizens from being able to exercise their legal rights.

Considering the Anti-NFA nature of many Sherriff's, it is understandable that one would want to fulfill the Federal CLEO notification requirements by using SHP or another agency that meets Federal requirements.

'Nuff said; it's time to go shooting.
 
I appreciate that frakn, but my last post before I disappeared I said you would get no further argument from me, I had no intention of posting anymore. I felt nothing good would be gained from continuing the argument so I figured best to just drop it and let it die.
 
@Scsmith42, you're right there is no actual law stating that the sheriff is the Cleo however it is specifically written into North Carolina State statutes and the North Carolina state constitution.

I did give an example showing where the words chief law enforcement officer was directly tied to being the sheriff. The sheriff is considered in North Carolina to be the highest law enforcement Authority in the county.

As far as whether a sheriff is supportive or not supportive of people owning guns or NFA items it really doesn't matter since they're not signing off they're simply getting notified so there really would be no reason to choose a different law-enforcement Source other than the sheriff because they don't have a say in the matter either way.
 
@Scsmith42,

I did give an example showing where the words chief law enforcement officer was directly tied to being the sheriff. The sheriff is considered in North Carolina to be the highest law enforcement Authority in the county.

In most states I always thought that the AG was considered to be the highest law enforcement authority in the state, and that the Sherriff's were below that office. I did not realize that the Sherriff's authority superseded a local Chief of Police, so that's good to know.
 
That's one reason why its an elected position and not appointed. Remember the AG is statewide, Sherif is the highest authority on a county level.
 
Now desiring to stop an argument is a sign of weakness? I beg to differ, only a fool fights in a burning house. There comes a time to cut your losses and drop it. What is your suggestion, we keep arguing until when exactly? Why do we keep arguing? Enlighten me.

Argue and your an *******, stop replying to insults and your a troll, asking to do the adult thing and stop arguing is weakness.

I mean seriously guys, if that's how you all feel I'm done here and gone.

The weakness is not showing you’re losing your argument with insults and saying ‘ I’m done , just stop already’

Up above you had ample time to address you being defensive with disrespectful insults being hurled.
Not only by me but another as well.

As said, telling us what someone said, is not good enough to win your argument. Showing the statue number that states exactly how you and your friends say it, would then stop it cold.
 
Mirac, Im done posting proof of what Im saying. And I didn't word it that way, did not say Im done stop already. We are supposed to be adults here not a bunch of kids. You want statutes you can google as well as anyone. You dont believe what I was told, call them yourself and hear it with your own ears. This thread has gone so far off the rails its ridiculous, I cant believe the mods didn't lock it 24 hours ago. Like I said earlier, before sending in your notification simply call and ask if they are the right recipient. See what they tell you. Simple, easy, risk free.

I had a horrible day yesterday, I just opened a new bottle of Elijah Craig 18 year old single barrel bourbon, and I'm going to enjoy that rather than research statutes to satisfy someone that thinks Im making **** up.
 
In most states I always thought that the AG was considered to be the highest law enforcement authority in the state, and that the Sherriff's were below that office. I did not realize that the Sherriff's authority superseded a local Chief of Police, so that's good to know.
In Missouri the county coroner in the highest. He is the ONLY person that can issue an arrest warrant for the sheriff
 
In Missouri the county coroner in the highest. He is the ONLY person that can issue an arrest warrant for the sheriff
Louisiana is the same way, I think the governor is the only one that can issue a warrant to arrest a sheriff. In some states the Sheriff is truly the high authority. Damn, the coroner... who would have thought!!
 
Louisiana is the same way, I think the governor is the only one that can issue a warrant to arrest a sheriff. In some states the Sheriff is truly the high authority. Damn, the coroner... who would have thought!!
I wonder how the coroner feels about NFA notifications. ;)

Hope you're feeling better!
 
@JGC1524 glad you and your wife made out of the accident in one piece. Also, sorry to hear about the loss of your cargo. They say "Don't cry over spilled milk." but I'm sure it's OK to shed a tear or two over spilled bourbon.

If you need anything to help get you through the accident recovery, just ask here. There are members near you that would be eager and willing to help. That's the way we are.
 
You are probably right, Im sure a database of who owns what is what they would like. You know how government is be it state or federal.
hey, more stuff we can agree on

Also, any crash you can walk away from definitely could have gone worse.
 
Mirac, Im done posting proof of what Im saying. And I didn't word it that way, did not say Im done stop already. We are supposed to be adults here not a bunch of kids. You want statutes you can google as well as anyone. You dont believe what I was told, call them yourself and hear it with your own ears. This thread has gone so far off the rails its ridiculous, I cant believe the mods didn't lock it 24 hours ago. Like I said earlier, before sending in your notification simply call and ask if they are the right recipient. See what they tell you. Simple, easy, risk free.

I had a horrible day yesterday, I just opened a new bottle of Elijah Craig 18 year old single barrel bourbon, and I'm going to enjoy that rather than research statutes to satisfy someone that thinks Im making **** up.

You are very new here... this is patty cake as far as rails go.
 
@JGC1524 glad you and your wife made it of that vehicle. Things could have been much worse. Prayers for speedy and full recovery. Please let us know if there is anything we can do to help until your back to 100%.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Back
Top Bottom