Depends on the buyer, but generally no. If you don't have time to part out the accessories individually, you're going to take a huge hit selling them with the gun they're on. You're significantly better off selling them separately, and even then you're frankly very likely to take a huge hit trying to sell things that aren't known for being especially desirable. I *start* my pricing for gun accessories at 75-80% and sometimes the item still doesn't sell until I've got it at 50% value. Maybe not even then. Chinesium tacticool parts are a dime a dozen and nobody is going to pay full price for the piece you got just to try out, so best to skip them whenever possible. Holsters and lights are not guaranteed to strike someone's fancy or fit their mission parameters, especially when people all have their preferences and brands they either love or avoid. When I have a gun that I have accessories for that I'd like to sell too, I've taken to listing the firearm listed either completely OEM spec, or with one or two things I just don't feel like swapping back out and don't care that I'm taking a loss on. Then from there, in a separate paragraph in the same ad, I'll say "will add X stock or Y grip or Z weaponlight for an extra (dollar amount)." That way the user sees the base price, doesn't get sticker shock, and from there they know I have accessories available and what I am willing to sell them for with the rifle. Usually at a discount because the buyer is conveniencing me in that I don't have to make a separe trip to the post office or to meet someone else. If they don't want those accessories? No worries, I just make a separate thread for those parts once the gun sells in the BST, or find another gun to put them on. Or put them in the spare parts bin to give to friends who need help completing builds or customizing their completely stock lower-end gun.
Ultimately, nobody is going to see the same value you do in the cash you put into a "custom build." They just don't care. They've got a set price that they subjectively associate with the brand/source of the gun. Their mind is made up the moment they read Anderson/PSA/Aero/whatever. If you want your gun to hold value, invest in guns that actually command a respected premium, and be prepared to have to wait for like-minded buyers that are willing and interested in paying for those premium names if you do decide to sell. In the end it's way easier to sell a $1500 Daniel Defense OEM-configured rifle than it is your $1500 Frankengun project on an Anderson lower receiver you picked up on sale one day. That's just the way it is.
Holsters, mags, lights? Things that are totally valid and worthwhile pieces of equipment that are worth having on the gun or the gun in? Don't just give those away for free. Sell those separately. Offer the buyer of the gun the chance to buy them at a discount, but don't just throw it in for free unless it's just not worth the time trying to sell those items separately (super-duper cheap items for instance, sure just throw those in because you'll only get a few dollars for them anyway). Just make informed decisions when purchasing these items to begin with, so you're sure of their quality and know they're desirable enough that people will want to buy them of their own merit. $5 generic knockoff holster? Meh who cares, throw that in. $75 holster, $100 light and $25 magazines? Absolutely no I'm not throwing those in for free. Well, unless it's a friend and I owe them a birthday present or something. Just also don't assume that just because someone's buying the gun from you, that they want those items too. Make it known they're available, but try to avoid insisting on package deals whenever possible. A little patience goes a long way in making a sale that doesn't completely wreck you as the seller. That way you don't impose yourself or your stuff on a prospective buyer, and you don't inadvertently give yourself the drive shaft either.
Now that I've just about sold off all the accessories I have that I don't use, I try to just steer clear of aftermarket mods and just focus on buying quality guns to begin with. I only accessorize guns I know I want to keep, and I try to keep the accessorizing minimal, and down to a few select high-grade desirable pieces I know people generally want (and I want them too). Don't accumulate a bunch of janky excrement nobody will buy from you if you don't like it, and you don't have to worry about the fact that you can't possibly sell it for what you have in it. Learn to use what comes stock in the gun you buy, or invest in a gun that comes stock with features you want already.
Ultimately, nobody is going to see the same value you do in the cash you put into a "custom build." They just don't care. They've got a set price that they subjectively associate with the brand/source of the gun. Their mind is made up the moment they read Anderson/PSA/Aero/whatever. If you want your gun to hold value, invest in guns that actually command a respected premium, and be prepared to have to wait for like-minded buyers that are willing and interested in paying for those premium names if you do decide to sell. In the end it's way easier to sell a $1500 Daniel Defense OEM-configured rifle than it is your $1500 Frankengun project on an Anderson lower receiver you picked up on sale one day. That's just the way it is.
Holsters, mags, lights? Things that are totally valid and worthwhile pieces of equipment that are worth having on the gun or the gun in? Don't just give those away for free. Sell those separately. Offer the buyer of the gun the chance to buy them at a discount, but don't just throw it in for free unless it's just not worth the time trying to sell those items separately (super-duper cheap items for instance, sure just throw those in because you'll only get a few dollars for them anyway). Just make informed decisions when purchasing these items to begin with, so you're sure of their quality and know they're desirable enough that people will want to buy them of their own merit. $5 generic knockoff holster? Meh who cares, throw that in. $75 holster, $100 light and $25 magazines? Absolutely no I'm not throwing those in for free. Well, unless it's a friend and I owe them a birthday present or something. Just also don't assume that just because someone's buying the gun from you, that they want those items too. Make it known they're available, but try to avoid insisting on package deals whenever possible. A little patience goes a long way in making a sale that doesn't completely wreck you as the seller. That way you don't impose yourself or your stuff on a prospective buyer, and you don't inadvertently give yourself the drive shaft either.
Now that I've just about sold off all the accessories I have that I don't use, I try to just steer clear of aftermarket mods and just focus on buying quality guns to begin with. I only accessorize guns I know I want to keep, and I try to keep the accessorizing minimal, and down to a few select high-grade desirable pieces I know people generally want (and I want them too). Don't accumulate a bunch of janky excrement nobody will buy from you if you don't like it, and you don't have to worry about the fact that you can't possibly sell it for what you have in it. Learn to use what comes stock in the gun you buy, or invest in a gun that comes stock with features you want already.
Last edited:
