Pershing v Panther, the Bates video

HMP

Well-Known Member
2A Bourbon Hound OG
Supporting Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2016
Messages
39,608
Location
TRIAD
Rating - 100%
28   0   0
I am currently reading SPEARHEAD, about a tank crew in WW2 in the 3rd Army
One of the pivotal engagements in it is Cologne and the new Pershing 'hunting' a Panther tank, which had just destroyed a Sherman.
Great book, IM learning more and more about WW2 and loving it.
And there was a part where they discussed this videographer who was filming everything and even told the Pershing crew where the Panther. I decided to look up the video.

A) it's WW2 quality
B) It's WW2, so it gets quite shaky during the blasts to hit the Panther
C) It's still super awesome
D) I watched while IM in this coffee shop, I have no idea if there is any audio, sorry.

Quick story with it - the Panther had the drop on the Americans, but Bates was already several stories up in the building to video when he saw the Germans turning their turret towards the intersection the Pershing was heading to. He had no course of action to help his buddies.
Since they, the Americans, knew where the Panther was, they already had their turret turned that way too, as they sped ahead towards the intersection.

When the Pershing got to the intersection everyone froze for a second - they were looking down the barrel of a Panther and knew they were done. But the Panther hesitated...for he, the commander, had not seen a Pershing before, this was one of the few which had made it to Europe and was very new, he assumed it was a German tank. He told his crew to hold fire, that it was a friendly. And that's when Clarence, the man at the trigger, pressed the little red button to fire off the first, of three, armor piercing rounds.

Once the first fired, the dust was brutal. The muzzle blast turned up so much dust and debris that he couldnt see if he hit or not, but it saw a slight silhouette and fired a second time. This time his commander (Earley?) said, "HIT!"
Then he pumped one more into the Panther, causing flames to erupt high out of the turret and ensuring that they had destroyed this huge beast.

 
That’s nuts! It’s surprising those guys climbed out of the tanks after molten metal and shrapnel were splashed all about in that confined space.
@7:30, what’s a riffle?
 
Last edited:
@7:30, what’s a riffle?
Dude, If Im honest, and i prefer to be - I only watched till after the third shot lol
I know there is SUPPOSED to be a shot of the crew. And because the pic is in the book - guy top left of the pic is Clarence, who the book centers around and pulled the dang trigger.

Also, not to you GET, but as a whole-the Panther commander went to his grave claiming he thought it was a friendly. He was a school teacher, died around the age of 90.
 
Super interesting. Thanks for posting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HMP
Back
Top Bottom